Returning Player Discussions

[Carlos Bernard]

I'm not going to call them Favorites or All Stars because im not sure what they are going to be yet.

Honestly there aren't many i'd like to see return. The only Pre Juror i'd consider bringing back for a Favorite (if I use it for more of a second chance season) but I don't think he lasted long enough to warrant him returning.


As for the people remaining. Benry is almost a lock to come back. One of my favorite all time players. As much as you dislike Erik is running the show and confessing and getting into it more than he usually does. He is almost a lock to come back.

As for the next tier i'd consider Kat, Bob Dawg, Diane, Chelsea and Sash as maybes.

Kat was awesome at first but as since SUCKED. Like words can't describe how annoyed I am with her sudden lack of desire to do anything. I feel the same with Chelsea to a less extent. She hasn't done much lately but can redeem herself.

Sash was almost a lock until he wanted to quit. I still think he'll end up being asked back but I need to make sure he's commited. Bob Dawg started off slow but has done pretty good since. The only thing against him is the fact no one else really talks about him. It makes me feel liek he's kind of like a Debbie that confesses (doesn't talk to anyone).

I never thought I'd consider Diane an all star but she has reboosted her image and she said she'd even consider taking Erik out. If she does that she'll be in but I think otherwise it will be tough to bring her in with the first five rounds doing nothing.

As for the others. Jolt has things going on which I feel is making him not as dedicated as I would of hoped. I understand his situation but I don't feel he's done anything to deserve another chance. Besides the endurance, Erinn has done nothing including a lot of the challenges. Mikey B as much as I like him as a host and a pesron. He doesn't do shit.

1. Benry
2. Erik
3. Sash
4. Chelsea
5. Bob Dawg
6. Kat
7. Diane
8. Greg
9. Erinn
10. Mikey

[Carlos Bernard]

If need be I will only ask 2 or 3 people to return but I would probably ask a maximum of 5 or 6.

[Amanda Kimmel]

Benry and Chelsea are the only two I see right now. Chelsea is at least plotting SOMETHING. And Benry is at least active in his confessional - something most people are not.

Kat's interest completely died with John. Sash wanted to quit and should have left last round, so he isn't eligible. Erik won't let me into his confessional and would have been out if he didn't pre-game, so he's out.

Nobody else has given me any sort of impression yet. Not a single one of them. I am so fucking bored with this game - the only things I come back for are 1) Benry's confessional and 2) Chelsea's avatar. Hence... they're my two picks.

Here I thought my season was pathetic... I had four freaking episode titles. This one is just... really sad. Virtually nobody is into it. And I don't get why. We need a PRETTY GIRLS to make things at least worth SOMETHING. Come on Benry and Chelsea... get a team together, take out Erik, and run shit.

[Amanda Kimmel]

Okay, Chelsea is in for sure. Sash has redeemed himself, so he's in too. And I maintain Benry.

That's just three. Four if you pick Erik, but I don't think a jerk who has only done well because of a pre-game deserves another chance. Especially because his own minions are blindsiding him. Love it.

[Carlos Bernard]

Erik's only pre games were Diane and Kim. He has no knowledge of who Benry and Sash actually are so this is pretty good with him.

Those 4 are the only players I will ask back and Idk what to do with whether they should be Favorites or All Stars. If all four are favorites we could potentially have FvF for Season 9 which I don't really want. I wouldn't like FvF till season 10 or 11.

I could split it up 2 v. 2

Erik would be an All Star and not a Fav because he wasn't very likable. Chelsea unless she wins would be a Favorite. Idk where I should put Benry in the Fav or AS category. I might put all 3 in AS 2 becuase there are a few of the people from the first half of the series I would consider bringing back for FvF even a couple of people from AS I who I feel should have another chance to be considered for the Legends season.

Who Knows though I really need to plan out the rest of the series.

[Amanda Kimmel]

I'm not sure if you should do an FvF at all. Just name all four to All-Stars. FvF is for series that have too many All-Star or Legend contenders that didn't reach their full potential. And to be honest, I know you'd probably want me back for FvF, but I'm not sure if I'd want to play given how blown my alias has been. I don't like being a target because of my past xD

If you do FvF, I say the only FvF person should be Sash (given when he wanted to quit) and the other three should be All-Stars. You have to name more AS than FvF, because you only have ten FvF spots in total. That should be season 10, probably...